10 Reliable Used Sedans That Feel More Premium Than Their Price Tag

Some vehicles just feel better and more inviting than the price you pay for them. It’s common to find reliable used sedans that give you a lot more quality and comfort for the money than you might expect. These used sedans have the premium feel you’re looking for, to go along with impressive reliability scores.

Reliable-Used-Sedans-That-Are-Cheaper-Than-Most-Compact-SUVs main image, two cars front 3/4 of each

Related

10 Reliable Used Sedans That Are Cheaper Than Most Compact SUVs

These sedans are priced keenly today and offer the very best reliability on the used market, with many hailing from American manufacturers.

2010 Hyundai Genesis

Fair Purchase Price Range: $3,914–$5,232 | Reliability Rating: 75/100

Hyundai

Most people would not consider the 2010 Hyundai Genesis to be a luxury car, but it can easily be one of the most premium feeling sedans you’ll drive. This car changed the game, giving drivers a fantastic choice when it comes to quality driving.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Hyundai sedan resembles a high-end luxury car and is easily one of the most reliable sedans that feels much more premium than its price would suggest. If you want a stylish car that doesn’t cost a lot, the 2010 Genesis is worth a look.

Pros

• Smooth and powerful engines
• Roomy interior with a comfortable ride
• Plenty of standard features

Cons

• Lacks brand cachet
• No AWD option
• Rear seat does not fold down

2010 Volvo S80

Fair Purchase Price Range: $4,500–$5,683 | Reliability Rating: 80/100

Volvo

You might not expect much from the 2010 Volvo S80, but this car can be one of the most enjoyable vehicles you will ever drive. For a small price, you’ll have a reliable luxury car with excellent safety scores and comfortable seats.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Volvo might not feel like it's as old as it is with the impressive array of advanced safety features included in every trim. The S80 has been built for a purpose, and that is to safely transport you and your family wherever you need to go.

Pros

• Well-equipped
• Impressive safety features
• Comfortable ride and seats

Cons

• Unimpressive base engine
• Forgettable driving experience
• Awkward navigation system interface

2018 BMW 5 Series

Fair Purchase Price Range: $19,329–$29,938 | Reliability Rating: 82/100

BMW

In most cases, you expect BMW vehicles to be athletic, fun, and energetic on the road. The 2018 BMW 5 Series could be those things, but it’s mostly a comfortable midsize luxury sedan that punches well above its weight class.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

You’ll find a lively array of engines to give you the desired power in this BMW sedan, but you’ll truly admire the posh interior, smooth ride, and good handling of the 5 Series, which can be a fantastic car for your daily driving needs.

Pros

• Wide range of powerful and relatively efficient engines
• A host of innovative features and leading technology
• Interior quarters are quiet and comfortable

Cons

• Evolutionary styling doesn’t stand out in a crowd
• Some interior materials are a bit below segment standards
• Handling takes a backseat to comfort

Fornt 3/4 shot of a 2023 Lexus IS500

Related

10 Dependable Used Sedans That Cost Less Than The Average Price Of A New Car In 2024

Discover 10 reliable sedans that offer great value, costing less than the average new car price in 2024, without compromising quality.

2010 Mercedes-Benz E-Class

Fair Purchase Price Range: $8,496–$10,061 | Reliability Rating: 83/100

Mercedes-Benz

The 2010 Mercedes-Benz E-Class was a redesigned model of one of the top luxury midsize sedans on the market. You might not think this car could be more premium than its price suggests, but when you want affordable driving at its highest level, this is it.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Mercedes-Benz midsize car brings the benefits of several body styles and an updated interior design quality that makes it much more enjoyable to drive than you might expect. If you want a sporty and comfortable coupe, you’ll find it with the E-Class.

Pros

• Superb ride and handling balance
• Potent engines
• Extensive array of luxury and safety features

Cons

• COMAND interface can be fussy to use
• Controversial exterior styling

2011 Cadillac CTS

Fair Purchase Price Range: $5,443–$8,086 | Reliability Rating: 84/100

Cadillac

The youthful exuberance and sharp styling of the 2011 Cadillac CTS are hard to beat. This impressive car is a reentry for Cadillac into the luxury world with something that makes drivers stand up and take notice.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Cadillac sedan signaled the end of the plodding land yachts from the brand and brought a new form of exuberance and fun to the table. The CTS is much tidier and more dynamic than previous Cadillac models, making it a great choice among used cars.

Pros

• Roomier cabin than similarly priced rivals
• Elegant interior design
• Capable and secure handling

Cons

• Not as nimble as similarly priced rivals
• Sport suspension may be too firm for some drivers
• Poor rear visibility

2010 Audi A6

Fair Purchase Price Range: $5,841–$7,733 | Reliability Rating: 84/100

Thomas Doerfer via Wikipedia Commons

When you step into the 2010 Audi A6, you might find some of the upgrades that were added to this car. It received a more powerful base engine, an upgraded navigation system with real-time traffic, and the latest version of the MMI electronics control system.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Audi midsize sedan has a lot to love and gets almost everything right. It has the qualities you want to see in your luxury sedan and makes driving pleasurable, especially if you have AWD. Get comfortable in one of the best cabins you’ll find among these used sedans.

Pros

• Finely finished interior
• AWD is available across the lineup
• Strong supercharged V6 engine

Cons

• Top-dog V8 is slower than the supercharged V6
• Not as memorable as some rivals

Hennessey Performance C8 Corvette Stingray Mod Upgrade Front View

Related

10 Slightly Used Sedans That Don't Care About The C8 Corvette's Performance

Can a sports sedan be faster than the C8 Corvette? These ten put the iconic Chevy to shame.

2009 Acura TL

Fair Purchase Price Range: $6,763–$12,596 | Reliability Rating: 85/100

Acura

When you’re looking for a used sedan that’s more premium than its price suggests, the 2009 Acura TL could be exactly what you want to drive. This car was completely redesigned for the 2009 model year to be larger and more comfortable with more power and available AWD.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Acura sedan is quicker and easier to maneuver at slow speeds than its predecessor, making it a hit. The styling wasn’t anything to write home about for some people, but you’ll spend your time in the cabin, where you can get comfortable and enjoy the drive.

Pros

• Tons of user-friendly high-tech features
• Spacious cabin
• Smart AWD system

Cons

• Interior lacks panache
• Lifeless steering in the base model
• Polarizing styling

2017 Genesis G80

Fair Purchase Price Range: $14,822–$18,388 | Reliability Rating: 85/100

Genesis

Even when it was new, the 2017 Genesis G80 undercut the competition as a car that was more premium than its price suggested. As a used sedan, this midsize luxury car has the upscale features you want at a great price.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

In addition to being a reliable used sedan, this Genesis has excellent crash test scores, giving you the peace of mind required to enjoy driving your family around. The 2017 G80 might feel a bit familiar; it was the Hyundai Genesis before becoming a luxury car of the fledgling brand.

Pros

• More affordable than similarly equipped luxury sedans
• Roomy and high-quality interior that stays very quiet at highway speeds
• Excellent crash test scores

Cons

• Doesn’t soak up road bumps as well as competitors
• Rear seat headroom is a little tight for this class
• Limited cargo room

2009 Lexus ES 350

Fair Purchase Price: $7,545 | Reliability Rating: 86/100

Bring A Trailer

The unapologetic nature of the 2009 Lexus ES 350 is almost admirable. This heavily weighted car is not meant for sporty driving but can be the ideal midsize luxury sedan for some enjoyable driving experiences on every road.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

When you want a car that feels great going from one place to another, this Lexus sedan is the perfect choice for you. It's not athletic, but its extremely comfortable and was one of the best-selling luxury cars in its class, proving the ES 350 has what consumers desire.

Pros

• Powerful and velvety-smooth V6
• Plush ride
• Sumptuous interior

Cons

• Conservative appearance
• No RWD or AWD

2015 Lexus GS

Fair Purchase Price Range:$17,136–$20,464 | Reliability Rating: 86/100

Lexus

The impressive size and comfort of the 2015 Lexus GS will make you feel like you’re in a flagship luxury sedan. While the GS is close to that, it’s not quite there. Still, this impressive sedan punches well above its price tag and is one of the most reliable used sedans you’ll find.

Most Popular Powertrain Specifications

This Lexus sedan was offered in several versions to be a sporty and fun alternative to the EX. This car has RWD or AWD, and it has a powerful setup that gives you the drive and performance you desire. There’s also a hybrid version for those looking for better fuel mileage.

Pros

• Capable handling with refined ride comfort
• High-quality interior
• Cutting-edge safety and entertainment technology

Cons

• Electronics interface can be distracting to use
• Excessive road noise enters the cabin
• Lackluster handling